Judge recommends no new trial for Texas death row inmate Rodney Reed

A Bastrop County, Texas, judge has recommended that death row inmate Rodney Reed not get a new trial, according to court documents.

“The Court has extensively considered the entire record of this case from its trial through the 10 day evidentiary hearing, at which the court was able to observe witnesses and assess their credibility concerning Applicant’s claims. This court recommends that relief sought by the Applicant be denied,” the recommendation signed by Judge J.D. Langley on Sunday said.

“Applicant has not proven by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable juror would have convicted him of capital murder,” Langley wrote. “Applicant has not proven by clear and convincing evidence that he is actually innocent.”

Reed, who was sentenced to death more than 20 years ago for the assault, rape, and strangling of 19-year-old Stacey Stites, has maintained his innocence.

Reed, who is Black, was convicted by an all-White jury, according to the Innocence Project, a legal organization that helps inmates prove their innocence through DNA tests.

The group has said the murder weapon was never tested for DNA evidence, that forensic experts admitted to errors in their testimony, and that a former prison inmate claims someone else confessed to the murder that sent Reed to prison, among other exonerating claims.

The case has united lawmakers, religious leaders, and celebrities such as Oprah, Kim Kardashian West and Rihanna in Reed’s defense.

In 2019, Reed was granted a stay of execution just days before his scheduled execution date of November 20, 2019. The stay meant the case would go back to a state judge in Bastrop County, where Reed was convicted.

Since Reed’s 1998 trial, “substantial evidence exonerates Rodney,” the Innocence Project said, in July.

“Rodney Reed’s legal team presented its case that Mr. Reed deserves a new trial in light of newly discovered evidence that supports his innocence claim. At the hearing before District Judge J.D. Langley, his legal team also presented evidence that prosecutors had withheld evidence and experts had given misleading testimony at Mr. Reed’s original trial in 1998,” the Innocence Project said.

Langley’s recommendation now goes back to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, which will decide whether Reed should be granted a new trial.

CNN has reached out to the Innocence Project for comment on Langley’s recommendation.

™ & © 2021 Cable News Network, Inc., a WarnerMedia Company. All rights reserved.


Wake up with Rachel Williams and WOGB

Wake up with Rachel Williams and WOGB

Rachel will start you day with all you need to make it GREAT!  Local updates, celebrity scoop and of course Green Bay’s Classic Hits!  So does it with a smile and her very own Green and Gold Style!  6 AM to 9 AM each Weekday on WOGB!

The WOGB Artist of the Month for January….Foreigner!!!!

The WOGB Artist of the Month for January….Foreigner!!!!

2022 is here!  Happy New Year!  2022 brings us more of Green Bay’s Classic Hits with our Artist of the Month, Foreigner!  Perfect songs for January….Like Cold As Ice and Feels Like the First Time to great power ballads like I Wanna Know What Love Is and Waiting for a Girl Like You!  January is…

AOTM: Live from Daryl’s House

AOTM: Live from Daryl’s House

Hall and Oates are considered the number one selling duo in music history, and for good reason. They came onto the scene in the 1970’s with their debut album and have since garnered six number one singles and six multi-platinum albums. A career spanning four decades, the duo continues to create music, tour, and work…

AOTM: A Bee Gees Musical is in the Works

AOTM: A Bee Gees Musical is in the Works

Started in 1958, the Bee Gees consisted of brothers Barry, Robin, and Maurice Gibb.  The band enjoyed consistent success throughout their career with their own music and music they wrote for others. Multiple awards and millions of albums sold highlight a band that has longevity and made a mark in the music industry. Now, the…